HIPAA action
HIPAA dvisory
 HIPAAdvisory > HIPAAction > HIPAA/LAW: Legal Q/A Phoenix Health Systems
news
regs
action
tech
wares
alert
live
latest
online HIPAA training
HIPAAstore
HIPAA help desk
search
contact us
site map

HIPAA/LAW:
September 2003


"Understanding the Final Rule for
Electronic Submission on Medicare Claims"

by Steve Fox & Rachel Wilson, Esqs., Pepper Hamilton LLP

The Department of Health and Human Services ("HHS") recently published the final rule for the Electronic Submission of Medicare Claims (the "Rule") mandated under the Administrative Simplification Compliance Act ("ASCA"). With few exceptions, ASCA requires that all claims sent to the Medicare Program on or after October 16, 2003 (the "Compliance Date") are submitted electronically. The Rule is only applicable to providers, practitioners, and suppliers who submit claims under Part A or Part B of Medicare. It does not apply to claims submitted by providers to Medicare + Choice organizations.

The Medicare Program is a covered entity subject to HIPAA regulations, as it falls within the definition of a "health plan" under HIPAA. Although the Transactions Standards promulgated pursuant to HIPAA (the "Transactions Standards") are applicable to electronic healthcare claims transmitted between covered entities, they do not require covered entities to submit claims electronically. In other words, as it relates to the submission of claims, the Transactions Standards are only applicable to covered entities when and if they choose to submit electronic claims. HHS estimates that approximately 139 million paper claims are submitted to the Medicare Program each year. Congress enacted ASCA to improve the administration of the Medicare Program by taking advantage of the efficiencies to be gained through electronic claim submission. The move from paper to electronic submissions is expected to result in significant savings for Medicare physicians, practitioners, suppliers, and other healthcare providers, as well as for the Medicare Program itself.

Electronic claims submission is only required for initial Medicare claims, including initial claims with paper attachments, submitted for processing by the medical fiscal intermediary or carrier that serves the physician, practitioner, facility, supplier or other healthcare provider. The Rule does not require any other transactions (for example: changes, adjustments, or appeals to the initial claim) to be submitted electronically.

Claims submitted via direct data entry mechanisms are considered to be electronic claims for purposes of the Rule. In addition, claims transmitted to a Medicare contractor using the free or low cost claims software issued by Medicare fee-for-service plans are also electronic claims for purposes of the Rule.

The only exceptions to the electronic claims submission requirement under the Rule are as follows:

  1. There is no method available for the submission of an electronic claim.

    Three situations fall into this category: (i) roster billing of vaccinations covered by the Medicare Program; (ii) claims for payment under Medicare demonstration projects; and (iii) claims where more than one plan is responsible for payment prior to Medicare;

  2. The entity submitting the claim is a small provider of services or small supplier.

    A small provider of services is a hospital, critical access hospital, skilled nursing facility, comprehensive outpatient rehabilitation facility, home health agency or hospice program with fewer than 25 full time equivalent employees (FTEs). A small supplier is a physician, practitioner, facility, or supplier with fewer than 10 FTEs.

  3. The Secretary of HHS finds that waiver of the electronic submission requirement is appropriate due to unusual circumstances.

    Unusual circumstances will be deemed to exist in any one of the following situations: (i) submission of dental claims, (ii) a service interruption in the mode of submitting the electronic claims that is outside of the control of the entity submitting the claim, but only for the period of the interruption and subject to the specific requirements set forth under the Rule, or (iii) upon demonstration to the satisfaction of the Secretary of HHS, that other extraordinary circumstances exist which preclude the submission of electronic claims.

Under ASCA, no payment may be made under Part A or B of the Medicare Program for claims submitted in non-electronic form. Absent a permitted exception to the Rule, paper claims submitted to Medicare will not be paid. Entities that fail to comply with the Rule may be subject to claim denial, overpayment recovery and applicable interest on overpayments.

HHS has made it quite clear that it does not intend to broaden the extremely limited exceptions discussed above. For that reason, if your organization expects to continue to receive Medicare payments after October 16, 2003 (and if you hope to remain in your present job), one hopes that you are well on the way to achieving compliance.

Read past HIPAA Legal Q/A articles.


Steve Fox, Esq., is a partner at the Washington, DC office of Pepper Hamilton LLP, www.pepperlaw.com . This article was co-authored by Rachel H. Wilson, Esq., an associate of Pepper Hamilton LLP. They may be reached at foxsj@pepperlaw.com. Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and should not be relied upon as legal advice.

Go to TOP