April 2003 News Archives
April
30, 2003 OCR Provides Guidance on Research Use of Data; Medical
Device Cos. as BAs Health Data Management reports drug company
Eli Lilly recently expressed concern to Department of Health and
Human Services (HHS) officials that the HIPAA privacy rule may impede
clinical research trials. In a response letter, Richard Campanelli,
director of the HHS Office of Civil Rights, wrote, "From the
point of view of privacy rule compliance and enforcement, all that
is required is that HIPAA authorizations used for research or other
disclosures comply with the requirements of the rule, whether the
HIPAA authorization form is created by the covered entity itself
or by a third party."
Last month, Campanelli responded to a letter sent by the Advanced
Medical Technology Association (AdvaMed) requesting HHS to clarify
whether, according to HIPAA, medical device companies are business
associates in their various roles as manufacturers, sponsors of
clinical research, providers of training, technical service and
support for their products, and FDA-mandated device trackers. Campanelli's
response explains the Privacy Standards' requirements in each of
these roles.
Read OCR's
guidance on research use of data (PDF).
Read OCR's
guidance on medical device companies' roles as BAs (PDF).
Read
"Protecting Personal Health Information in Research: Understanding
the HIPAA Privacy Rule" (PDF) from HHS' National Institute
of Health.
April
30, 2003 High Court Rejects Challenge to SC Patient Records
Rules USA Today reports the US Supreme Court rejected a challenge
Monday to South Carolina regulations that let health inspectors
examine and copy patient records at clinics that perform abortions.
A Greenville, SC clinic and physician argued that the regulations
unconstitutionally intrude on women's privacy. The challengers were
supported by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists,
which urged the justices to hear the case, saying the policy "violates
basic principles of medical confidentiality." The high court's
rejection of the appeal -- made in a one-sentence order -- sets
no national precedent. But it allows the South Carolina regulations
to take effect and closes a chapter of litigation stemming from
the state's mid-1990s regulation of abortion providers.
Read
more.
April
28, 2003 Senator Seeks Assurance Privacy Enforcement Will
Be Reasonable Sen. Judd Gregg (R-NH), chairman of
the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP),
has written to HHS Secretary Tommy Thompson, to bring to Thompson's
attention "serious concerns that have been raised by many providers
of vital health care services, including state Medicaid agencies,
about the impact of the medical privacy rule under HIPAA."
In his April 24 letter, Gregg asks Thompson "to publicly assure
providers and other covered entities that the medical privacy rule
will be enforced in a reasonable, non-punitive manner and that special
consideration will be given to the rules most complex requirements
for which the department has provided no formal guidance.
Read Sen. Gregg's letter (PDF).
April
21, 2003 WEDI Alerts HHS Over Impending TCS "Train
Wreck" On April 15, the Workgroup for Electronic Data Interchange
(WEDI) sent a letter to HHS Secretary Tommy Thompson advising him
on how the industry will be making the short-term transition from
its current state to a successful implementation of the HIPAA Transaction
and Code Set (TCS) standards. WEDI believes that a substantial number
of covered entities are not far enough along to achieve compliance
by the October 16, 2003 TCS deadline. In its letter, WEDI identifies
several courses of action which may avoid the "train wreck"
that will result from reversion to paper claims or stoppage of cash
(payment) flows.
Related to this, the HHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) recently
reported that about one in five state health agencies say they will
not be compliant by the October 16, 2003 deadline. Only one of the
five territories with Medicaid programs expects to be compliant
by October.
View OIG's reports:
Read
WEDI's letter (PDF).
April
21, 2003 Homeland Security Issues NPRM on Critical Infrastructure
Data Submission CNET News reports that last week, the new
Department of Homeland Security published a set of proposed regulations
designed to convince corporate America to hand over infrastructure
information to the government, promising that it will be kept in
the strictest confidence. The proposal sweeps broadly, covering
any data submitted to the government about any real or possible
attack on "critical infrastructure or protected systems by
physical or computer-based attack" or any programming errors,
glitches or bugs that could endanger important services.
Read
CNET's article, "Uncle Sam Wants to Know Your Weakness."
Read
the proposed regulation.
April
21, 2003 HIMSS Goal: Quicken Electronic Records Adoption
Health Data Management reports more than 70 provider organizations
and information technology vendors have signed a declaration calling
for a summit and additional action to support universal implementation
of computer-based patient records systems. The Healthcare Information
and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) wrote the declaration as
part of a pledge to
- Define the electronic health record and its functionality to
facilitate adoption and interoperability.
- Develop a standard summary patient data set to achieve initial
interoperability among providers.
Meanwhile, iHealthBeat reported that few hospitals and only about
5% of US primary care physicians use EMRs, according to an article
in Technology Review.
Read
more.
April
21, 2003 Security Agency Selects Privacy Watchdog
The Washington Post reports a former privacy official for the controversial
Internet advertising firm, DoubleClick, was named chief privacy
officer of the Department of Homeland Security last week. Lawyer
Nuala O'Connor Kelly will review whether the department's collection
and use of personal information about US citizens is legal and appropriate.
Read
more.
April
15, 2003 HHS Releases Interim Final Rule on Enforcement;
Posts New Privacy Guidance The interim final rule, "Civil
Money Penalties: Procedures for Investigations, Imposition of Penalties,
and Hearings," establishes rules of procedure for the imposition,
by the Secretary of Health and Human Services, of civil money penalties
on entities that violate HIPAA standards. This rule will be the
first installment of the "Enforcement Rule" which, when
issued in complete form, will set forth procedural and substantive
requirements for imposition of civil money penalties. In the interim,
HHS is issuing these rules of procedure to inform regulated entities
of its approach to enforcement and to advise regulated entities
of certain procedures that will be followed as it enforces the Administrative
Simplification provisions of HIPAA. The interim final rule will
be effective May 19, 2003 and provides for a 60-day comment period.
This interim final rule will cease to be in effect on September
16, 2003.
The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) published HIPAA Privacy Rule
and Public Health Guidance, including appendices on selected Privacy
Rule concepts and definitions and sample text that can be used to
clarify public health issues under the Privacy Rule. OCR also posted
three documents to assist covered entities in complying with the
Privacy Rule:
View the text of the
Interim Enforcement Final Rule.
April
14, 2003 HHS Secretary Thompson and the Press: On Reaching
the Privacy Deadline On Friday, Department of Health and Human
Services' Secretary Tommy Thompson issued a press release on the
HIPAA Privacy regulations going into effect today. Sec. Thompson
focused on how the new federal health privacy protections "will
reassure patients of the confidentiality of their medical records...[and
give them] greater access and more control over...[the] personal
information...in their own medical records." Meanwhile, newspapers
across the nation have been focusing on today's Privacy Rule compliance
deadline, alerting the public of what to expect when interacting
with the healthcare industry. Major papers running stories are:
Read the text of Sec. Thompson's
release.
April
11, 2003 HIPAA Roundtable Scheduled for April 30 A National
HIPAA Implementation Roundtable has been scheduled by the Centers
for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for April 30, 2003 from
2:00 PM - 3:30 PM ET. It will focus on HIPAA Administrative Simplification,
specifically electronic transactions and code sets, and security.
The call in number is 1-877-381-6315. The conference identification
number is 8688774. CMS is requesting that callers RSVP to Alikia
Brown at Abrown1@cms.hhs.gov
or by fax to 410-786-1710.
The transcript of the February 28 Roundtable, focusing on security
and electronic transactions and code sets, is now available; the
transcript of the Privacy Roundtable held in March in conjunction
with the Office of Civil Rights will be coming soon.
Read the February
Roundtable transcript (PDF).
April
11, 2003 Citizens for Health, American Psychoanalytic Assn.
File Last-Minute Privacy Rule Lawsuit A lawsuit was filed yesterday
federal court in Philadelphia to try to block the HIPAA privacy
law that is to take effect Monday, reports the Philadelphia Inquirer.
The plaintiffs in the suit, the Citizens for Health consumer group
and the American Psychoanalytic Association, charge that the new
law will give insurance companies, drug companies and police more
access to individual medical records. The lawsuit asks the court
to invalidate the parts of the privacy rule that say patient consent
is not needed for sharing medical information with health plans
or billing companies and their business associates.
Also yesterday, Rep. Edward J. Markey (D-MA) and Rep. Ron Paul
(R-TX) separately introduced legislation regarding patient privacy.
Markey's bill (HR 1709), the "Stop Taking Our Health Privacy"
(STOHP) Act first introduced in October 2002, requires patients'
permission before their records could be used or disclosed for treatment,
payment and health-care operations. Paul's bill (HR 1699), the "Patient
Protection Act," repeals the HIPAA Privacy regulations, abolishes
a national patient identifier, and prohibits the use of federal
funds to develop or implement a database containing personal health
information.
Read more regarding the lawsuit.
Read
the text of Markey's bill, HR 1709 (PDF).
April
10, 2003 Balancing SARS Patients' Privacy with Public's Need
to Know The Miami Herald reports that Florida's Department of
Health issued news releases last week detailing the state's ability
to monitor an outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS),
but short on specific information about the afflicted. Current University
of Miami president Donna Shalala, Secretary of Health and Human
Services in the Clinton administration, thinks that the state Health
Department has it right, saying that individuals shouldn't be identified
and potentially stigmatized.
Read
more.
April
10, 2003 HPP to Monitor HHS Enforcement of Privacy Rule
The Health Privacy Project (HPP) announced today it will be monitoring
the oversight and enforcement of the HIPAA privacy rule by HHS
Office for Civil Rights (OCR) to ensure that patients privacy
rights are enforced effectively. HPP has posted a model complaint
form on its website and is asking the public to provide HPP with
copies of complaints submitted to OCR. OCR has yet to post an online
complaint form, even though most health care providers and health
plans are required to comply with the new privacy law by April 14,
2003.
Read more.
April
1, 2003 CMS to Hold HIPAA 101 Satellite Broadcast The
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services on April 16 will present
a free satellite broadcast to inform health care providers about
the administrative simplification provisions of HIPAA. The Medicare
Learning Network broadcast, "HIPAA 101: the Basics of Administrative
Simplification," can be accessed by anyone with an analog satellite
dish. It also will be available at local carrier and intermediary
sites and at selected Indian Health and Tribal Health facilities
in 25 states.
The program will cover:
- The history of HIPAA and its benefits
- How to tell if you are a 'covered entity' under HIPAA
- The standards that have been adopted for electronic transactions
and code sets
- Why the Designated Standards Maintenance Organizations may be
important to you
- What you need to do to be compliant with the administrative
simplification provisions of HIPAA
- How HIPAA's rules and deadlines will be enforced
More
information.
|